ГУЛаг Палестины

infiltrated by the government. By the time of our second hearing Mr. Sharansky has already became a minister. And Mr. Malka knew it. So

he presented the view of Israeli government as an "independent" view that time as well as in all other occasions. She clearly exposes the

source of all the manipulations with the refugees from Israel in Canada: Israeli government! That paragraph also exploits the topic , which

was closed by my answer during our first immigration hearing. Mrs. Malka asked me how can I explain the statistic from Israel that no

Russian-speaking people were regestered complaining against the police. I shown then all the receipts of my appeals I have submitted to

police, to the Ministry of police, to the Ministry of Internal Affairs and to police headquarters in Tel-Aviv. And I said that this is the

explanation because my mails were unanswered and my complains were never registered. I also presented an article, which gives

absolutely precise, reliable and competent information that nothing can be really done against police in Israel. And the story about a

policeman who get a fine because of his refusal to help an Arab as an "evidence" looks like a clowned.

It was clear for the tribunal that it's impossible to avoid comments about the total ignorance of the whole documentation, which we

presented. It was clear that something must be said. This is why the next paragraph was composed to say just anything about that and was

designed to say nothing in particular. The tribunal claims that all our documents were rejected because its members took into consideration

only "absolutely reliable" documents. And it looks like there were no such documents among these we presented... In reality documents like

the letter from the Minister of Culture Mr. Amnon Rubinschtein, which shows that persecutions against me weren't just a chain of

coincidences, Amnesty International's confirmation, Lev Ginsburg's affidavit, receipts of my letters to police and other organizations, other

official papers can not be considered as "reliable" or "not reliable". Another thing is that their existence may be recognized or not

recognized. The tribunal chosen the second way: to ignore them. It's your choice now to decide if that happened as the result of the

tribunal's partiality. But we ask you to read over the paragraph #4 on page 3 of the decision where the tribunal rejects in advance even the

possibility of existence of such a category of refugees as "refugees from Israel". How could you expect then another attitude to any

documents from a tribunal, which refuse to recognize refugees from Israel in principle? On the other hand that tribunal's ability to

distinguish between "reliable" and "non-reliable" documents is reflected in documents they chosen themselves to support their point of

view: one of them is incompetent when it speaks about Israel , another one has "0" credibility because it was presented during the hearing

as an independent source, and in reality is the voice of Israeli government (Mr. Charansky's affidavit), and the 3-rd can proof nothing

because it is a part of the declaration of the state of Israel (the Law of Return), and nothing more.

The suggestion that my wife refused to collaborate with the tribunal is a pure lie what can be heard on the tapes from the hearings.

And the ignorance of the medical documents is the thing from the same category.

Please, believe us that our lives were in a real danger in Israel and that this danger just increased since we came to Canada. We were

threatened from Israel even here, and we presented the proof. Please, save our souls!

Lev Gunin

NEXT DOCUMENT: [[[DOCUMENT NUMBER 5 - CONCLUSIVE DECISION]]]

Short DESCRIPTION of GUNINS CASE

PREVIOUES DOCUMENT NEXT DOCUMENT

From Family Gunin, Montreal, November, 1998

Dear Friends!

Please, try to treat this letter as an unusual appeal, not just a desperate cry for help and justice.

In October 1998, the Federal Court of Canada issued a second decision in family GUNIN's appeal. (The 1-st one was positive). That tragic

decision resumed our refugee claim, which took 4 years of our lives.

Let us make a brief description of events, which took place before that sad date.

The head of the family, Lev GUNIN, as all members of the family, was born in Bobruisk, Belarus, ex-USSR. Senseless, ridiculous

coincidences in 1971-72 turned him, a secondary school student, young composer, and advance piano player, into a person, persecuted by

Soviet authorities. They tried to prevent him from entering collegial university studies; however, his persistence and a lucky miracle broke

that wishes circle, and he received first collegial, and then university degrees in music. In spite of that, L. GUNIN could not build a

successful composer's carrier because of persecutions. In the same time, he played a specific role in ex-USSR, Belarus, and other

countries' cultural life. He's the author of novels, stories, poetry, contemporary and electronic music, works in history, essays, musicology,

music history, philosophy, etc. His articles were published in a number of newspapers all over the world.

In 1979-1986, Lev became an object of wide humiliations. He was beaten by somebody, who has links with militia (police) and KGB. The

authorities stood up in defense of the attackers. They persecuted L. GUNIN even more for bringing the attacker to trial. In another incident

he and his brother - they were hunted by two well-coordinated groups: mobsters, and a gang of youngsters. "Hunters" were also leaded by

militia (police). Later brothers GUNIN were interrogated by police /KGB men. Lev's brother Vitaly became a victim of secret medical

manipulations.

L. Gunin has multiple links with the cultural elite, famous personalities and dissidents in Moscow, St. - Peterburg (Leningrad), Vilnius,

Warsaw, and Belarus. He also has co

Western countries.

1980-s. Because of persecutions L. GUNIN's decided to participate in the dissident movement. There are the main directions of his

dissident activities:

1. Participation in Human Rights movement and links with the most famous human rights activists.

2. Membership in underground literacy circles.

3. Defense of the Old City of Bobruisk from revelation and demolition.

4. Journalism and editorial functions for underground magazines.

5. Cooperation with forbidden (or unwelcomed) in ex-USSR NTS (People's Labor Union) and the National Front of Belarus.

6. Participation in the Jewish national movement.

7. Creation of ideologically independent and stylistically controversial music, prose, poetry, philosophy, and historical, political, and other

works.

1985-1989. A conflict erupted between leading by L. GUNIN group - and the powerful institution of Israeli emissaries to USSR, and

controlled by them Jewish political Mafia. (Their goals - devastation of the local Jewish cultural life, confiscation of huge aid from the

Western Jewish communities, and concentration of the propaganda of immigration to Israel - L. Gunin was fighting). He also confronted

three important personalities - Kebich, Alimbachkov, and Lukashenko. All of them became top political figures later: first one short before,

and the two others - after his departure from USSR (The 1-st one became the Prime Minister of Belarus, 2-nd - major of Bobruisk, and the

3-rd is the present dictator of Belarus).

.

His attempts to emigrate to USA or Germany - to save his brother's life - failed. All attempts to obtain an Israeli visa for permanent